Amar, Akbar and Anthony are working on a project. Working together Amar and Akbar can complete the project in 1 year, Akbar and Anthony can complete in 16 months, Anthony and Amar can complete in 2 years. If the person who is neither the fastest nor the slowest works alone, the time in months he will take to complete the project is
Show solution
Correct answer: 32
Think of this as: three people pair up in all possible ways, and each pair's combined speed is given. From those three pair-speeds we can recover each person's individual speed — then pick the middle one.
Let the monthly work-rates of Amar, Akbar, and Anthony be , , and respectively, measured in projects per month.
Step 1 — Convert every pair-time to a pair-rate.
| Pair | Time together | Rate (projects/month) |
|---|---|---|
| Amar + Akbar | 1 year = 12 months | |
| Akbar + Anthony | 16 months | |
| Anthony + Amar | 2 years = 24 months |
Step 2 — Add all three equations to get the combined rate.
The LCM of is , so:
Therefore:
💡 Teacher tip: Adding the three pair equations always gives twice the total rate, because each person appears in exactly two of the three pairs. Halving it gives the rate of all three working together.
Step 3 — Subtract each pair-rate to isolate each solo rate.
Since , subtracting any one pair-rate leaves the third person's rate:
-
Amar:
-
Amar alone takes months.
-
Akbar:
-
Akbar alone takes months.
-
Anthony:
-
Anthony alone takes months.
Step 4 — Rank the three solo times and pick the middle one.
| Worker | Solo time | Rank |
|---|---|---|
| Akbar | 19.2 months | Fastest |
| Amar | 32 months | Middle |
| Anthony | 96 months | Slowest |
The person who is neither the fastest nor the slowest is Amar, and he takes 32 months working alone.
Answer:
💡 Takeaway: Whenever you're given all three pair-times, add the three pair-rates and halve — that instantly gives the combined rate. Subtracting each pair-rate back out then yields every individual rate. No simultaneous equations needed.