Set-up: a three-subject Venn diagram with one relationship tying the overlaps together. Use the total-students identity to pin down the "all three" region, then push the target region to its maximum.
There are 150 students; Physics 75, Maths 111, Chemistry 40. Everyone takes at least one subject.
Step 1 — Name the overlaps using the given relation. Let the Physics–Maths overlap be 2b. We're told Physics–Chemistry = Chemistry–Maths = half of that =b. Let t be the number taking all three.
Step 2 — Apply inclusion–exclusion (union =150).
150=75+111+40−(2b+b+b)+t=226−4b+t,
so t=4b−76.
Step 3 — Write each region. Let p,m,c be the "only one subject" counts. Standard bookkeeping gives, after substituting t=4b−76:
p=b−1,m=b+35,c=2b−36.
Step 4 — Bound b using non-negativity.
- The "exactly Physics–Chemistry" region =b−t=76−3b≥0⇒b≤25.
- At least one student takes all three: t=4b−76≥1⇒b≥20.
So b ranges over 20 to 25.
Step 5 — The target: Physics but not Maths. That's all of Physics minus its overlap with Maths, =p+(b−t):
#(P∖M)=(b−1)+(76−3b)=75−2b.
This is largest when b is smallest, i.e. b=20:
75−2(20)=35.
Step 6 — Verify at b=20, t=4. Only-regions p=19, m=55, c=4; pairwise-only regions 36,16,16; all three =4. Total =19+55+4+36+16+16+4=150 ✓, and the overlaps are 40,20,20 as required ✓.
Answer: 35
💡 Read the target carefully: "Physics but not Maths" is the whole Physics circle outside Maths — the Physics-only slice plus the Physics-and-Chemistry-but-not-Maths slice — not just "Physics only".