The passage given below is followed by four alternate summaries. Choose the option that best captures the essence of the passage. Tamsin Blanchard, curator of Fashion Open Studio, an initiative by a campaign group showcasing the work of ethical designers says, “We're all drawn to an exquisite piece of embroidery, a colourful textile or even a style of dressing that might have originated from another heritage. [But] this magpie mentality, where all of culture and history is up for grabs as 'inspiration', has accelerated since the proliferation of social media...Where once a fashion student might research the history and traditions of a particular item of clothing with care and respect, we now have a world where images are lifted from image libraries without a care for their cultural significance. It's easier than ever to steal a motif or a craft technique and transfer it on to a piece of clothing that is either mass produced or appears on a runway without credit or compensation to their original communities."
Show solution
Correct answer: C
A para-summary answer must capture both the passage's main point and its full scope — miss either and the option is wrong.
Main point and scope: taking motifs, techniques or styles from any culture without permission, credit, compensation or respect is appropriation; social media has made this "magpie mentality" worse. The essence is the ethical judgement plus its breadth — any cultural group, and all of these harms together.
Why C is the answer: "Taking fashion ideas from any cultural group without their consent is a form of appropriation without giving due credit, compensation, and respect" states both the judgement (it is appropriation) and the full scope (any group; credit, compensation and respect).
Why the others fail:
- Copying embroidery/textile designs from native communities is stealing and they need compensation — narrows to two examples and to compensation alone, dropping credit, respect, and the "any culture" breadth.
- Media has encouraged mass production; images are copied without care for ethnic communities — shifts the emphasis onto mass production and misses the core charge of appropriation.
- Cultural collaboration is the need of the hour; indigenous designs should be showcased worldwide — flips the tone into a feel-good recommendation the passage never makes.
Answer: C